26 Jun 2010

Review – Warcraft: MAGE

Expanding on an initial series of manga exploring some of the stories and myths  in the Warcraft universe, Blizzard have moved on to produce a series of books focusing on the ten in-game classes. Published by the popular Manga form Tokyopop, the volumes are created by a mix of story writers and artists.

The second in the series to be printed, Warcraft: Mage was written by Richard A. Knaak and drawn by Ryo Kawakami. It runs at nearly 200 pages and can be picked up for about £8 or 10 euros from your local bookseller, although places like Amazon have it listed for less.

It’s probably worth pointing out that I bought my own copy, mainly because I was interested in seeing how the Mage storyline would develop. I’d heard various rumours about how Knaak treats both Mages and Dragons, but used this as my first dip into the stories he created.

As a story, Warcraft:Mage is a simple enough affair. Aodhan Falamar is a reckless boy who comes from a long line of warriors and paladins. Turning his back on family tradition and against his father’s wishes, he instead chooses to follow in the footsteps of his recently slain cousin Crevan and become a Mage of Dalaran.

During his training, the city of Dalaran is attacked by the Blue Dragonflight. As the attack progresses, Aodhan must make difficult choices between family, power and loyalty, with the entire floating city hanging in the balance.

The difficulty with the story lies in it’s predictability. It’s clear from the outset which path the tale will take, and sure enough there’s nothing surprising on the way. And although the shortness of the tale can be forgiven somewhat, the shallowness can’t. The formulaic cliché of family betrayal feels tired and worn out, with the characters feeling bland and lacklustre.

In fact, the characters are one of the major drawbacks of the book. There is a certain blandness and lack of emotion displayed by the central characters, causing the central theme of the story to feel somewhat fake. It’s hard to feel sympathetic towards Aodhan’s situation largely because he didn’t seem to be that bothered by it himself. None of the inner conflict you’d normally expect was visible.

As a book about mages, the magecraft feels relevant and passable. The old Presence of Mind-Pyroblast routine was described, making the book feel immediately dated. That said, existing mage spells were used to convey action instead of relying too much on the Jania Proudmoore method of just creating whatever effect you need.

The art style isn’t to everyone’s taste, but it was clear that variety of references had been used in order to give the settings a reasonably authentic feel. There are however some glaring omissions that aren’t immediately obvious, the first being the lack of anything other than human Mages in Dalaran. Bearing in mind that this is supposed to be when the city is in-flight to Northrend, the absence of even Gnomes from the pages seems very odd.

The second problem is more of a knock-on issue – because Dalaran felt like an almost exclusively human city, it didn’t have that cosmopolitan feel that I’d normally associate with it. If anything it had more in common with a flying Hogwarts University than a multicultural hub.

Ultimately, I can’t find much to recommend Warcraft: Mage. There’s no real expansion of Mage lore, nor is there anything in it’s covers that we didn’t know already. More fundamentally it’s not even an entertaining read. The cliché-ridden storyline and lacklustre characters are coupled with a portrayal of the Warcraft universe that simply didn’t resonate.

I may be asking for too much from a 200-page manga, but I doubt it.

Like this? Try these other related posts:

Tags: , , ,

7 Responses to Review – Warcraft: MAGE

  1. Vrykerion says:

    /sigh. Can’t say I’m surprised. Knaak and his ilk have made the fantasy genre the derivitive cesspool of cliche that makes it so hard to get into today. :(

    As for Dalaran being exclusively human, while yes, in WoW we see a nice spread of the majority of races across the city, Dalaran is populated by some 3,000 people by WotLK most of which I am assuming are human (Why? Because it’s a human city from human lands. It was part of the Alliance of Lordaeron, and before that part of the Empire of Arathor. They welcomed the high elves when they formed the Council of Tirisfal to help deal with the Legion though.) So while yes, some acknowledgement of the other races would be nice, I wouldn’t be shocked to see a walk through the city and see only humans. (Contrast? Well, how about Tijuana? Walk around Tijuana enough and you’ll see plenty of Americans. But it’s complete possible to not see a single one all day. How about that?)

    Sorry, that became a bit rant-ish. :P
    Vrykerion recently posted..Barrens Beautification Project BeginsMy Profile

    • Gazimoff says:

      I understand where you’re coming from, but…
      *it’s set in the time between TBC and Wrath
      *so it’s long after the Violet have been recruiting people to help with Karazan
      *it’s even longer since Gnomeregan fell and the Gnomish Mages have been unleashed upon the world.
      *there are a lot of Gnomish NPCs in Dalaran allied to the Violet Eye.

      So the book itself might be justified, but in comparing the book and the game world there is a definite visual discord.

  2. Rivs says:

    Well I want to stay away, but I know myself anything concerning mages I pick up regardless.
    Rivs recently posted..Shove your “ism” where the sun don’t shineMy Profile

    • Gazimoff says:

      I’m a sucker for mage-related stuff, including the tabletop RPG sourcebooks. This has probably been my most dissapointing purchase so far.

  3. Pellex on Hyjal says:

    *Yawn* Why do they always seem to assume we want WoW books from the Alliance point of view? As a diehard Hordie, I would have liked to see a Horde mage book. Maybe once they finish all the class-based stories they can come back and do “World of Warcraft: Horde Mage.” (Though even then, I’m not sure I’ll be able to stand the arwork.)

    Thanks for saving me a few bucks.

    • Gazimoff says:

      Yeah, it’s a real shame. There are so many other mage stories that aren’t that well known. Why the choice was made to focus on what is probably the most well known part of mage lore, I’ll never know. Oh well… perhaps an opportunity for the Blizz story competition?

  4. Knaak’s writing in Stormrage was equally lackluster. Pretty much assume you can skip whatever he’s written and read the summary on WoWWiki to be less disappointed.

    Eagerly looking forward to Christie Golden’s take on Cataclysm, though.
    Christopher S. Penn recently posted..Twitpocalypse postponed due to vuvuzelasMy Profile